For most of modern political history, photos of a candidate in bondage gear could have ended a campaign within a news cycle. In New York's 1st Congressional District this year, they became a fundraising boost and a line of campaign merchandise.
What happened
In September, the New York Post published archived photos of Chris Gallant, the Democratic candidate for the Long Island seat, modelling leather and bondage gear for Mr S Leather, a San Francisco fetish retailer. His lawyer confirmed the photos were authentic and consensual, and that they were taken around 2010, when Gallant was 21 and serving in the Army National Guard. Gallant, an openly gay Army pilot and former firefighter, said he was neither embarrassed nor ashamed.
Rather than distance himself, he leaned in. His campaign began selling "Make Politics Sexy Again" merchandise, and according to Fortune he raised $929,825 in the July to September quarter, which closed a little over two weeks after the story broke, against roughly $609,000 for the Republican incumbent, Nick LaLota. LaLota accused Gallant of cashing in on his modelling past while avoiding debates.
In the end Gallant lost. The Associated Press called the race for LaLota, who had 51.1 per cent of the vote to Gallant's 48.9 per cent in AP's count as of 6 November. Fortune's analysis also found that much of the money arriving after the photos came from outside the district: in the month that followed, only about 24 per cent of itemised donations came from individuals inside NY-1.
I'm not interested here in who should have won the seat. What interests me is what those photos were supposed to do to him, and why they didn't.
The old playbook
Outing someone as kinky has long worked as a political weapon because it relies on an assumption most people never examine: that a person's sexual interests reveal something defective about their character or judgement.
The evidence doesn't support that assumption. Research on BDSM practitioners has generally found no sign of poorer mental health than in the wider population, and some studies have found better wellbeing on certain measures. Kink is also common, with fantasies about power and surrender among the most widely reported sexual fantasies in the research.
The photos themselves showed an adult man taking part in a consensual shoot for a legitimate business more than fifteen years ago. Nobody was harmed, so the sense of scandal had to come from the reader's own discomfort.
Leather has also been part of gay men's culture for decades, and treating leather imagery as inherently scandalous echoes much older ways of shaming queer men.
What refusing shame does
Shame depends on secrecy and on the expectation of disgrace. An exposure story usually needs its subject to apologise or disappear. Gallant responded quickly and plainly, said he wasn't ashamed and joked about it, which left the story with very little to do.
For many kinky people, the fear of being found out does more harm than anything they actually do in the bedroom. It shapes who they confide in and how much of themselves they bring to work and family life. Watching someone be exposed in the most public way possible and keep going matters, especially for people who are still hiding.
The limits of one story
I don't want to overstate what this proves. Gallant had a lawyer and a national profile, and he was running at a moment when a gay candidate refusing to be shamed was a story in its own right. Most people outed as kinky have none of that.
For a teacher, or a parent in a family law dispute, being outed can still cost a job or be used against them. And because so much of the money that followed the photos came from outside the district, the fundraising surge tells us more about who was cheering from a distance than about whether voters on Long Island had changed their minds about kink. A close congressional race is shaped by far more than one news story, and the result says little about kink either way.
What I hope we take from it
I would like to see the day when photos like these barely make the news, because people understand that a candidate's consensual sex life has no bearing on whether they can do the job, and judge them on their record instead.
Until then, Gallant's refusal to apologise is a useful example for kinky people of what being found out can look like when shame doesn't get the last word. If you are carrying the weight of a secret like this, you deserve support that doesn't treat your desires as the problem.
Sarah Newbold is a social worker and the founder of Progressive Therapeutic Counselling, an online practice in Australia offering kink-affirming counselling and specialist support across sexuality, gender and relationship diversity.
